Thursday, May 21, 2009

Post Poll Analysis

( Inspite of the slimy title and it's slimier political undertones, this is of course about something much worse -my own narcissistic poll about my irrelevant future which i had conducted. )

<a href="http://www.buzzdash.com/polls/what-should-i-do--162382/">What should I do ?</a> | <a href="http://www.buzzdash.com">BuzzDash polls</a>

A surprising 117* (sic. / sick) people voted . Since own optimistic estimate was 35, let me say i am more than shocked at the surprise voter turnout. Now as is usually the case with most elections and polls, most of the options doesn't make sense and to make it even more convoluted there were combination options resulting in people voting for some clubbed together items which they wouldn't have voted for individually in the first place.

the conclusions are as follows
  • 85% think that i should not continue my sabbatical

  • 51% think that i should not go to IISc

  • 43 % think that i should not go to IIMB

Even though I knew that the IIM brand was a bit over rated, I am suprised to find that only 26 % really found some value in it by itself. The only way of explaining this would of course be by criticizing the weirdness of the Poll conductor (moi) and the resulting demography selected. Another notable fact is that most people who felt that i should not join IIM Bangalore or for that matter a managerial career at all, were concerned enough to actually come forward and talk to me about it. So eventhough in the numbers game IIMB wins, i believe more people really "care" about me not ending up a corporate bloodsucker or at worst screw up two years of my life doing pointless and completely irrelevant stuff (er.. haven't i been doing that for quarter a century now? ).
  • 36%** think that i should not do GSoC

I still remember how ecstatic/surprised/shocked I was when i first got funded by google for my idea in the field of architectural morphology, mentored by Portland State University. I think I had walked around 3 or 4 km before coming to my senses. The fact that the news had come to my attention after around 10 days of the official date shows my expectation level. Over the next years, I had the opportunity to work with amazing people. This year when I got funded again for working with brl-cad, as grateful as i am for this amazing opportunity, I'd be lying if i said it had the same sense of euphoria as the first time. It is true that i learned much more in the last year than any other time. More than anything else, there is the apprehension of whether I would be able to do justice to my own milestones and plan. Add to that two computers failing on you by frying up, things are not exactly very convivial.

Some other obvious facts
    The loser was of course IISc at 10 % . In spite of being the most elite research institute in India and not to mention an amalgalm of a lot of brains and talent.. seems like it is not so much of a crowd-puller . Either that or the voter populace really hates me. Even after being coupled with GSoC we have only 28% who seem to favour IISc. My dear friend gurra's elementary explanation for these votes are the people who are in the waiting list at B, further showing the apprehensions about the value? of a research position in Indian academia.
     The single largest winner was the option of being at IIM Bangalore along with IISc and GSoC ( never mind almost an impossible thing to handle ) with 31 %.
     Coupled with other things - either gsoc alone or gsoc+iimb - IISc has achieved a 49 % support.

Next Step
The logical move would be to wait out for a month ( *** June 22nd is the registration at IIM Bangalore) and work on the gsoc implementation as much as I can ( hopefully the laptop returns  in a couple of days) If nothing happens I would be just another guy who ended up beneath the pergolas at IIM Bangalore purely out of indecision / not having anything else to do ( which if I am not mistaken is a pretty sizeable portion of every batch there. ) I sincerely hope that I don't screw up anybody's life in there ( that would be the egotistic narcissism cropping up .) and equally importantly not get kicked out considering my Kharagpur attendance records.

Further facts regarding what would happen at Bangalore, for instance would i still have control over my breath , only time will tell. Regarding IISc, I still have time to decide and probably too little time to give. Things I am most excited about Bangalore in "roughly no particular" order.

1. Friends
2. Sports climbing
3. Nice ground/weather to run.
4. Possibly better swimming pools ( which won't burn my pockets ? )
5. Better access to gymnastics facilities?
6. Drama (Theatre .. not to mention the Human drama )
7. Riding (Bangalore Amateur Riding Institute)

Notes:
* 8 people who informed me that they did not vote but stated that they would like me to do something not among the options, have not been taken into consideration in the percentages.
** plus those of the 15% Sabbatical votes who though the sabbatical did not imply gsoc
*** The fact that I got a fees waiver for the first year does influence things to a large extent.

6 comments:

Mantri said...

All conclusions are statistically insignificant .... cannot reject the null :D

iisc life. said...

Hope to see you at IISc.

Ankit Anand said...

All conclusions are always statistically insignificant.

DT said...

@Mantri, Goldie of Noida

yep statistical conclusions are always irrelevant :P

but on an unconnected? note, as some have pointed out to me, considering i am already into dealing with pointless trivialities at moderately great depth and coming to useless and irrelevant conclusions using analytic approaches, not to mention statistics ( and even a smaller domain at that), i might not suck so bad at consultancy :P

Note : Future corporate bloodsucking employers - Please ignore this.

@iisc life
nice blog you have bhondooo

Anonymous said...

[i] i might not suck so bad at consultancy :P [/i]

Going by the reason you have cited to draw the above conclusion, even this very statement can be rendered irrelevant (read: inconclusive)

Knowing you Mr. Thomas, I very certainly can't see you as one of those selling soaps! But given the complexity of the situation, IIM isn't that bad an option considering that you 'ld need to earn your bread and butter after all; and more importantly, address your joblessness.. :P
However, I am sure that you would go ahead to do something beyond those conventional lines, given that you have (apparently) been the torchbearer of Entrepreneurs at Kgp! :P

Good Luck Mr. Thomas for the road ahead!
I sincerely hope that something more tangible does crop up in the next 30 days. :)

DT said...

@anonymous

1. forget selling soaps, i might get kicked out in the first term thanks to my sincere attendance experience.

2. hate bread, love butter . but in any case I am looking forward to bangalore as more of an extended sabbatical than anything else.

3. nothing is wrong with conventionality . I just seem to suck at it.

4. nope, nothing tangible cropped up :)